You are here

Scotiabank gives long abuse to cancer victim trying to reclaim her silver

Section: Daily Dispatches

11:15a ET Sunday, July 18, 2010

Dear Friend of GATA and Gold (and Silver):

The difficult attempt of a cancer-stricken Toronto woman to exchange her Scotiabank silver certificates for real metal, witnessed last week by a writer for the Globe and Mail, whose account of the matter is appended, recalls the difficult attempt of Harvey and Lenny Organ to do the same thing with the same bank. (See The bank's mistreatment of the Toronto woman is so outrageous that perhaps some of those who were skeptics of the Organs' story will begin to wonder if there isn't after all really a bullion banking policy to discourage buyers from taking possession of their metal precisely because the banks are selling far more claims to metal than they have actual metal.

CHRIS POWELL, Secretary/Treasurer
Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee Inc.

* * *

An Unkind Complicatedness

By Christie Blatchford
The Globe and Mail, Toronto
Saturday, July 17, 2010

In the end, nothing else would do for Scotiabank but that Amar Patel -- 73 years old, bald from chemotherapy, in the throes of metastatic breast cancer -- should drag her aching bones down to the bank's head office in downtown Toronto.

The trip from her airy apartment above the Indian Rice Factory, the landmark restaurant she founded in 1970 and has run ever since, was an agony of no fewer than five transfers -- from the hospital bed in her living room to a commode, from commode to the chair lift for the first set of stairs, from that chair to the next chair lift for the second set, from that chair to a walker, from walker to the car.

This exercise took 59 minutes and the best efforts of her son Aman, daughter-in-law Deepa, and restaurant employee Chandan Sindhwal.

... Dispatch continues below ...


Prophecy to Become Coal Producer This Year
with 1.5 Billion Tonnes of Resource

Prophecy Resource Corp. (TSX.V: PCY) announced on May 11 that it has entered into a mine services agreement with Leighton Asia Ltd. to begin coal production this year. Production will begin with a 250,000-tonne starter pit as planned in August, with production advancing to 2 million tonnes per year in 2011. Prophecy is fully funded to production and its management team includes John Morganti, Arnold Armstrong, and Rob McEwen.

For Prophecy's complete press release about its production plans, please visit:

I should note that despite her illness and pain, Mrs. Patel, who hadn't been out of the apartment for almost two months, was gracious, beautiful in a red-striped caftan, and, but for occasional moans when the car hit a rough patch of road, remarkably uncomplaining.

All she wanted was to do was take delivery of the silver the bank was holding for her in the form of the certificates she’d bought decades earlier.

It was, or ought to have been, an uncomplicated transaction.

Another major financial institution, TD Bank, managed to handle the same transaction within a couple of days, and delivered the bullion to Mrs. Patel's local branch for pickup.

By this Thursday, Mrs. Patel had done the following to obtain Scotiabank's agreement to give her what is rightfully hers:

In early March, Aman, a Toronto criminal lawyer, had attended the downtown headquarters to explain his mom’s situation. He suggested that either a bank official go to her apartment to witness her signature (he even offered to pick up and drive back the official) or consider meeting his mother in the car outside the bank to save her a bit of the journey: Both requests were rejected.

On March 17, Aman faxed the silver certificates to his mom's local Scotiabank branch and then drove his mother there; they were advised she would have to attend the King/Bay office downtown.

For a time, Mrs. Patel gave up; she was hoping she could tackle it in a few weeks or months, when she was better and had her strength back.

When that didn't happen, she hired a Bay Street lawyer and, through him, signed a power of attorney appointing Aman as her attorney.

In early July, Scotiabank asked first to "pre-inspect" the power of attorney, then demanded the original; then pronounced it unacceptable because it wasn't sealed; then insisted that a notarized copy, with covering letter from the lawyer, be produced; finally, the notarized POA had to be submitted to the home branch, then the bank's legal department.

Even with these various approvals finally in place, Aman was told (being a lawyer, he has notes of all these conversations and e-mails) that the bank could still deny the transaction if it was deemed not to be in Mrs. Patel's "best interest."

So she hired another lawyer, this time to help her get what was hers.

Then the bank said it had to decide if the transaction was to be for the benefit of the attorney, from a business point of view. In other words, Scotiabank would decide if the transaction made business sense -- not Mrs. Patel, or her lawyer, or Aman, who had her power of attorney.

This Thursday, having heard nothing from the bank about whether it would honour the now-approved and vetted POA, Aman called and got Judy McBride, the head of customer service at King and Bay Streets. She told him the bank would not honour the POA and that Mrs. Patel had to come down in person.

Aman again explained how weak his mother was, to no avail.

That afternoon, Aman, his wife and Chandan managed to carry out the five transfers and get Mrs. Patel in the car.

Once they arrived downtown, Aman went in to ask, one last time, if Scotiabank would at least dispatch people outside to do the signing in the car. Absolutely not, came the answer.

They got Mrs. Patel into the commode chair and into the lovely, high-ceilinged headquarters with its polished marble floors they went.

Ms. McBride asked a number of questions, in my presence. Among them: "Do you understand what this transaction is that is taking place? We're taking your certificates and giving you the actual bullion? Why would you want to do that? It's more difficult for you to cart around."

At this point, Aman's seemingly endless store of patience was exhausted and he said -- mildly, I thought, in the circumstances -- "That's none of your business."

Ms. McBride said that it was, that "simply putting a POA in place doesn't give carte blanche," that the bank had a responsibility too, and asked Mrs. Patel, "Why would you need the physical metal?"

Ms. McBride said the bank "reserves a right to ask questions," because, she said, "We need a comfort level."

Bank spokesman Joe Konecny denied the bank ever insisted Mrs. Patel had to come in person, said they were "willing to act" on the POA, but that "a heightened level of due diligence was required for a number of reasons," among them, bizarrely, that the transaction wasn't initiated at her home branch, although that branch had directed her downtown.

In any case, after about an hour, Mrs. Patel finally got her silver.

But it must have been a mortifying experience for this very dignified woman to make such a trip in her bedclothes, and the whole thing struck me as a profoundly condescending and arbitrary intrusion of bank functionaries into Mrs. Patel's and her family's business. And what if her son wasn't a lawyer who knew how to fight back? What if she'd had a stroke and wasn’t able to sign the documents?

If she wanted to buy crack cocaine with that silver, or sleep with it at her side, that's her call, because it belongs to her, not the bank. The bully-boy functionaries might want to find a comfort level around that notion.

* * *

Join GATA here:

New Orleans Investment Conference
Wednesday-Saturday, October 27-30, 2010
Hilton New Orleans Riverside Hotel

* * *

Support GATA by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:

Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:

Or a video disc of GATA's 2005 Gold Rush 21 conference in the Yukon:

* * *

Help keep GATA going

GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:

To contribute to GATA, please visit:


Sona Resources Expects Positive Cash Flow from Blackdome,
Plans Aggressive Exploration of Elizabeth Gold Property

On May 18, 2010, Sona Resources Corp. (TSXV: SYS, Frankfurt: QS7) announced the release of a preliminary economic assessment for gold production at its flagship Blackdome and Elizabeth properties in British Columbia.

Sona Executive Chairman Nick Ferris says: "We view this as a baseline scenario for gold production. The project is highly sensitive to the price of gold. A conservative valuation of gold at $1,093 per ounce would result in a pre-tax cash flow of $54 million. The assessment indicates that underground mining at the two sites would recover 183,600 ounces of gold and 62,500 ounces of silver. Permitting and infrastructure are already in place for processing ore at the Blackdome mill, with a 200-tonne per day throughput over an eight-year mine life. Our near-term goal is to continue aggressive exploration at Elizabeth and develop a million-plus-ounce gold resource, commencing production in 2013."

For complete information on Sona Resources Corp. please visit:

A Canadian gold opportunity ready for growth