You are here
George Will: What is the Federal Reserve for, exactly?
Central bank's 'too leveraged to fail' principle has created a poisonous bailout culture
* * *
By George Will
The Washington Post
Friday, November 29, 2024
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/11/29/federal-reserve-bailouts-moral-hazard/
With a recession deepening and the 1982 midterm elections approaching, Federal Reserve chair Paul Volcker was summoned to the Oval Office, where Ronald Reagan was sitting with his chief of staff, James Baker.
When Baker said Reagan wanted to give Volcker an "order" about interest rates, the 6-foot-7 central banker immediately stalked silently from the room.
He did not take orders.
... Dispatch continues below ...
... ADVERTISEMENT ...
Cerro de Pasco's Assay Results at Quiulacocha
Indicate Consistency at Depth and Laterally
Company Announcement
Tuesday, December 3, 2024
MONTREAL -- Cerro de Pasco Resources Inc. (CSE: CDPR, OTCQB: GPPRF) reports that the 40-hole drill program at its Quiulacocha Tailings Project in central Peru has been successfully completed, providing more than 1,000 samples, of which 177 have been assayed to date, including the SPT04 drillhole released on October 15.
Key Highlights:
-- 177 assay samples from nine drill holes, equivalent to 15% of the current drill program, indicate an average silver grade of 1.72 ounces per tonne of silver (53.64 g/t), 37% higher than the average of shallow auger samples reported by Brophy (2012) in the north and central sections of the project. ...
... For the remainder of the announcement:
Donald Trump is determined to break institutions to the presidential saddle, so people wonder: Could he fire the head of the Fed? (Probably not. Besides, Chair Jerome H. Powell's term expires in May 2026.)
More interesting questions are: What is the Fed for? And is its "independence" a license for mission creep?
John H. Cochrane and Amit Seru of the Hoover Institution think the hyperactive Fed has become too ambitious in its interventions in the economy and social policy. Their proposal is the title of their essay "Ending Bailouts, At Last," in the Journal of Law, Economics, and Policy.
The problematic behavior is a century old and bipartisan: When large financial institutions are in danger of failing, government bails them out by bailing out their creditors. The 1907 financial crisis led in 1913 to the Federal Reserve Act establishing the Fed, which did not prevent the 1933 bank collapse. This led to deposit insurance and many regulations, which did not prevent Continental Illinois Bank's 1984 failure, the savings and loan crisis of the 1980s, and many other bumps on the road to 2008.
"Never again, we say, again and again," wrote Cochrane and Seru. Bailouts multiply, larger each time, spreading to highly leveraged industrial companies, as in the auto bailout of 2009. "Too leveraged to fail," they wrote, "might be the summary of our new regime."
Too leveraged is a consequence of interest rates too low for too long, combined with confidence that the bailout culture is forever and unlimited.
During the pandemic, the market for Treasury bonds became fragile, so the Fed lent bond dealers money to buy the bonds, "then turned around and bought the Treasurys from the dealers a few days later." Cochrane and Seru wrote that the Fed almost has an implicit policy of buying "whatever quantity" necessary to prop up corporate bond prices.
They noted that the Biden administration's "paycheck protection" program made "forgivable loans" -- Washington-speak for gifts -- "to small businesses with 500 or fewer employees to cover their business costs, including mortgage interests, rent, utilities, and up to eight weeks' payroll costs." It is one thing for the accountable political institutions to do this, quite another for the Fed to lend "on lenient terms to the real economy, not just the financial sector."
Throughout the economy, Cochrane and Seru wrote, leverage has been rewarded: "If you saved and bought a house with cash, if you saved and went to a cheaper college rather than take out a big student loan, or if you repaid that loan promptly, you did not get money." In today's permanent central-bank-run credit system, "Borrow. Borrow especially if you are big or part of a big and politically influential class of borrowers. As with student loans, borrow from the government." You might not have to pay it back.
When Silicon Valley Bank accepted many large, uninsured deposits, then got in trouble, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. -- the government -- guaranteed all deposits. So now, wrote Cochrane and Seru, "effectively markets expect all deposits of any size to be guaranteed going forward, at least during any newsworthy event."
The Congressional Budget Office projects budget deficits of 5 to 8% of gross domestic product forever. And this, Cochrane and Seru correctly believe, is too unrealistic. CBO assumes no crises, recessions, wars, pandemics or -- most laughably -- spending increases. But even this optimistic debt path "simply cannot happen."
"Everything is finite, including the U.S. government's ability to borrow real resources in a crisis," wrote the authors. Student loans, mortgage and rent forbearance -- "it seems impossible for our democratic government to lend money to its citizens and demand repayment, especially in bad times." And bad times are when money might be tight for the government.
"We have," Cochrane and Seru wrote, "once-in-a-century crises every 10 years these days."
"Crisis" has come to mean "the possibility that someone, somewhere might lose money." And "contagion" now denotes a vague fear that "any ripple anywhere might bring down the financial system."
Societies get what they incentivize. Moral hazards -- incentives for perverse, risky behaviors -- are now sown throughout American life. Cumulatively they might break the government before Trump's eccentric Cabinet nominees can.
* * *
Support GATA by purchasing
Stuart Englert's "Rigged"
"Rigged" is a concise explanation of government's currency market rigging policy and extensively credits GATA's work exposing it. Ten percent of sales proceeds are contributed to GATA. Buy a copy for $14.99 through Amazon:
* * *
Help keep GATA going:
GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:
To contribute to GATA, please visit:
