You are here

Ross Norman: Central bank manipulation of gold wouldn't surprise me

Section: Daily Dispatches

By Ross Norman, CEO
Sharps Pixley Bullion Brokers, London
Sunday, October 16, 2016

GATA Secretary Chris Powell has invited me to reply to his October 15 commentary --

-- in which he replied to my article of the 14th, wherein I rebutted an academic study that concluded that the London gold price fix was manipulated:

If you look at my article (and indeed previous ones) you will see that my aim is to defend the integrity of the London gold fix as a method to derive a fair benchmark price. My aim is not to defend the integrity of the institutions operating the fix.

The reason for this is that I simply do not have the visibility over all fixing members and their every trade that I would need to say that these guys are 100-percent honest. No one does.

... Dispatch continues below ...


A Lone Congressional Candidate Is Campaigning on the Gold Standard

The New York Sun just endorsed Connecticut Republican congressional candidate Daria Novak, based on her support for restoring the gold standard:

Daria needs us to contribute $1,000, $500, $250, $100, $50, or whatever we can afford in the fiat money that is sleeping in our checkbooks. As the Sun wrote, "She vows to crusade" on the gold standard "as key to getting job creation, economic security, and upward mobility back at a sizzling rate." Novak has been endorsed by gold standard and sound money advocates George Gilder, Lawrence Kudlow, Jimmy Kemp (Jack Kemp's son), and Jeffrey Bell ... along with Steve Forbes, who calls Ms. Novak "the prosperity heroine."

To donate to Daria's campaign, please visit:

Daria will personally thank all contributors.

Daria Novak is gold's lonely champion. Give her your backing and put a voice for gold in Congress.

This message was authorized by Daria Novak for Congress.

That said, I do know that the market traders at the banks are heavily outnumbered by in-house compliance people and it would be close to impossible for them to do anything improper even if they wanted to. The level of forensic investigation into any position taking is actually quite staggering. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary I simply don't have a view either way.

I might add that I have the same ambivalence toward GATA.

Powell described my assessment as "weak" but it's a shame that he didn't go on to say why. I would be interested to hear his views about the fixing process. I would love to hear how he would derive a benchmark.

For bad guys there are many other far easier ways of cheating a client than the fix should they want to -- such as front-running. The fix has too many moving parts.

Regarding Deutsche Bank, I understand that the bank's position is that it has actually paid a fine for all possible sins -- whether the bank is guilty or not -- simply to allow the bank to move beyond the crippling affect of handling so many lawsuits. In fact the board director in charge of Deutsche Bank's legal affairs was promptly sacked by the rest of his board for having agreed to the settlement because of the reputational damage he had caused.

You might ask why they would chose to seek a settlement. My understanding is that they simply wanted to move forward and were prepared to take a financial hit to do so. This is not uncommon in legal cases. I don't doubt that, if there were specific infringements in relation to the fix, these would have been made public by now.

The key issue that Powell raises is whether central banks are active in the precious metals markets -- or, to use his words, "manipulating the price." The short answer is that I don't know for sure but I would not be surprised.

Central bank intervention in markets is nothing new, nor is their redefining of methodologies around data to suit their purposes -- for example, hedonic adjustments.

Gold is often said to be the reciprocal of trust in official planners and as such a weak gold price might seem to reflect well on them and their policies. There are others who would see merit in a weak gold price, including short sellers in the futures markets, physical sellers of gold, and others.

I do worry about the ongoing desire to portray the bullion markets as manipulated and think it is actually counterproductive. Those who are minded GATA's way are already invested in gold. Those who are not (the remaining 99.5 percent of the population) will conclude that they should not bother with gold because it is said to be a corrupt market. Such accusations are a total passion killer for those who might be minded to invest.

To be clear, I am not a spokesman for the banks, nor for the London Bullion Market Association. Like Powell, I just happen to have an opinion. Our positions are probably not that far apart. I just prefer to deal with known knowns and have less time or regard for conjecture.

* * *

Join GATA here:

New Orleans Investment Conference
Wednesday-Saturday, October 26-29, 2016
Hilton New Orleans Riverside
New Orleans, Louisiana

Help GATA by purchasing DVDs of GATA's London conference in August 2011 or GATA's Dawson City conference in August 2006:

Or by purchasing a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:

Help keep GATA going

GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:

To contribute to GATA, please visit: