You are here
FT's Gillian Tett provides the rationale for gold price suppression
3:36p ET Friday, May 11, 2012
Dear Friend of GATA and Gold:
Explaining "financial repression" as the coercion of investors to purchase government bonds that pay negative real interest rates, Gillian Tett of the Financial Times this week provided the perfect rationale for the Western central bank gold price suppression scheme -- all without mentioning gold at all.
That is, investors might be powerfully discouraged from buying such crappy bonds and thereby subsidizing profligate governments if, meanwhile, a rising gold price was trumpeting a rate of inflation substantially greater than the bond interest rates or if gold itself, via capital gains, was offering a substantially better return than those bonds.
In an essay published in The Wall Street Journal last December, recently resigned Federal Reserve Board member Kevin M. Warsh was among the first to complain about "financial repression," which he described as a matter of policy makers' "suppressing market prices that they don't like":
http://www.gata.org/node/10839
We can infer that gold's is among those disliked prices if not the primary price in mind -- but we can only infer, since, despite GATA's importunings, not even The Wall Street Journal itself, publisher of Warsh's remarkable essay, could be persuaded to ask him, for purposes of a news story, to specify the prices suffering "financial repression" and to explain whether he learned of such price suppression during his recent service at the Fed.
On a planet with actual financial journalism, such questions might be posed directly to central bankers and former central bankers, with public answers demanded and refusals to answer reported prominently. On this planet -- or at least in what is still sometimes called the Free World part of this planet -- we have to settle for mere hints and implications. But, as shown by Tett's column this week, appended here, such hints and implications can be found all over the place.
CHRIS POWELL, Secretary/Treasurer
Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee Inc.
* * *
Repression on Bonds Heralds Masochism
By Gillian Tett
Financial Times, London
Thursday, May 10, 2012
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/58078892-9abc-11e1-94d7-00144feabdc0.html
Almost exactly a year ago, the economists Carmen Reinhart and Belén Sbrancia wrote a path-breaking International Monetary Fund paper about "financial repression." It initially caused many Western investors to blink. For while such "repression" has been extensively discussed in emerging markets in recent years, not many people in America knew what this dark-sounding phrase meant.
(Answer: "Financial repression" occurs when governments engineer a situation in which investors feel compelled to buy bonds at unfavourable rates, ie below the prevailing level of inflation, thus helping to reduce national debt.)
How times change. A year later, the word "repression" is being bandied about at investor conferences across the Western world. No wonder. In the eurozone, there are growing signs that governments in places such as Spain and Ireland are "encouraging" -- if not forcing -- banks and state pension funds to buy public sector bonds, at potentially unfavourable prices.
... Dispatch continues below ...
Be Part of a Chance to Discover
Multi-Million-Ounce Gold and Silver Deposits in Canada
Northaven Resources Corp. (TSX-V:NTV) is advancing five gold and silver projects in highly prospective and politically stable British Columbia, Canada.
Check out the exploration program on our Allco gold/silver project :
-- A large (13,000 hectare) property, covering more than 15 square kilometers of a regional mineralized trend just 3km from a recently announced 1.2-million-ounce gold and 15-million-ounce silver deposit.
-- The property hosts historic high-grade silver workings and many mineral showings as well as former mines at the property's northern and southern boundaries.
-- A deep-penetrating airborne geophysics survey has just been completed on the entire property and neighboring deposits and its results are eagerly awaited.
To learn more about the Allco property or Northaven's other gold and silver projects, please visit:
http://www.northavenresources.com
Or call Northaven CEO Allen Leschert at 604-696-3600.
Meanwhile, in America something just as remarkable is under way: Investors are gobbling up government debt at unfavourable rates without needing to be "repressed" at all. This week demand for 10-year Treasuries was so high -- as fears exploded about the eurozone -- that the US government sold debt with a record low coupon of 1.75 per cent. And while the nominal yields on 10-year Treasuries, of about 1.91 per cent, are above last year's lows, in real terms they are in negative territory, given inflation over 2.5 per cent.
Anybody buying Treasuries, in other words, is essentially agreeing to subsidise the US government in coming years -- unless you believe that deep deflation looms. Call it, if you like, a form of "voluntary" repression; either way, it will almost certainly end up helping the US state, to the detriment of investors.
So can it continue? If you ask US policy makers and financial officials that question, you are apt to hear an embarrassed cough. Last week, for example, I questioned a group of Federal Reserve presidents at a debate at the University of California at Santa Barbara. In public, none of those Fed leaders was willing to describe the picture as overt "repression." After all, they said, monetary policy in America is independent, meaning that the raison d’etre of the Fed's super-loose monetary policy is to boost economic demand, not support fiscal policy. If this helps cut debt, this is just a happy accident; or so the argument goes.
Nevertheless, what is crystal clear is that Fed and Treasury officials alike are determined to keep those Treasury yields ultra low, if not negative in real terms, for the foreseeable future. And they may well succeed. Never mind the fact that the Federal Reserve has been gobbling up Treasury bonds, as part of its loose monetary policy; or that private sector banks are raising their holdings of government debt to satisfy new regulations, such as the Basel liquidity coverage ratios. What is more fascinating is how investors are stealthily embracing a "voluntary repression" mindset too.
Consider what has happened with US pension funds. Five years ago, these typically had a 60 per cent equity allocation, with 30 per cent in bonds. But last month, according to the Milliman survey, the top 100 funds placed 41 per cent of their $1,300 billion worth of assets in fixed income -- topping the equities ratio for the first time. That shift might have looked rational a few years ago; after all, annualised returns for Treasuries in the past decade have been 6.8 per cent, versus 2.9 per cent for the S&P 500.
But the timing looks terrible, given that, as David Goerz, chief investment officer of HighMark Capital says, "Aa 2 per cent Treasury yield is equivalent to a price/earnings ratio of 50x compared to a forward earnings multiple of 13x for the S&P 500 today." Or to put it another way, it would make more sense, Goerz says, for funds to switch back into equities.
Alternatively, managers such as Scott Minerd of Guggenheim, think investors should be looking to corporate bonds for decent returns. But the experience of 2007 and 2008 has left investors so scarred -- and scared -- they are more focused on capital preservation and liquidity, than returns. Or to put it another way, if everyone else (including the Fed and banks) is piling into Treasuries, many investors want to follow the crowd. Correlation of fear rules the day.
This creates big risks in the long run; if inflation suddenly surges, growth resumes, or there is another US fiscal row that creates default scares, prices could swing and many investors will get badly hurt. But, in a world awash with spare cash, it is a fool’s errand to predict exactly when this bubble might burst. I suspect we could see this voluntary repression prevail for some time; or call it, if you prefer, the era of mass market financial masochism.
* * *
Join GATA here:
Las Vegas Money Show
Caesar's Palace, Las Vegas
Monday-Thursday, May 14-17, 2012
http://www.moneyshow.com/tradeshow/las_vegas/moneyshow/
Committee for Monetary Research and Education
Spring Dinner Meeting
"Money and the Corporate State"
Union League Club, New York, N.Y.
Thursday, May 17, 2012
http://www.cmre.org/
Vancouver World Resource Investment Conference
Sunday-Monday, June 3-4, 2012
Vancouver Convention Centre East
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
http://www.cambridgehouse.com/event/world-resource-investment-conference
Standard Chartered's Earth Resources Conference
Wednesday-Thursday, June 20-21, 2012
J.W. Marriott, Hong Kong
http://www.standardcharteredsignatureevents.com/earths-resources/welcome...
Hong Kong Gold Investment Forum
Monday-Wednesday, June 25-27, 2012
Renaissance Harbour View Hotel, Hong Kong
http://www.hkgoldinvestmentforum.com/
Toronto Resource Investment Conference
Thursday-Friday, September 27-28, 2012
Toronto Sheraton Centre Hotel
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
http://www.cambridgehouse.com/event/toronto-resource-investment-conference
New Orleans Investment Conference
Wednesday-Saturday, October 24-27, 2012
Hilton New Orleans Riverside Hotel
New Orleans, Louisiana
http://www.neworleansconference.com/
* * *
Support GATA by purchasing DVDs of our London conference in August 2011 or our Dawson City conference in August 2006:
http://www.goldrush21.com/order.html
Or by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:
Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:
http://gata.org/node/wallstreetjournal
Help keep GATA going
GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:
To contribute to GATA, please visit:
